D1516 is the CDT code for a fixed space maintainer spanning both sides of the upper arch, such as a Nance appliance or transpalatal arch.
- When to use: One cemented appliance crosses the palate to hold space on both sides of the upper arch, reported once for the arch with no quadrant.
- When not to use: The lower arch is D1517, a one-sided fixed appliance is D1510 per quadrant, and a removable upper appliance spanning both sides is D1526.
- Billing note: Plans differ on one bilateral appliance versus two unilateral ones, so verify which the plan pays before the case is planned.

What D1516 reports
D1516 reports one fixed appliance that holds space on both sides of the upper arch. The appliance is usually anchored by bands on the permanent first molars, one on each side, and joined by a wire that crosses the palate.
Two designs dominate, and both are D1516:
- Nance appliance. The palatal wire carries a small acrylic button that rests against the front of the palate, which helps keep the molars from drifting forward.
- Transpalatal arch. A wire runs straight across the palate from molar to molar, without the acrylic button.
Delta Dental of Michigan’s 2026 space maintenance criteria name both as fixed bilateral maintainers, alongside the lower lingual holding arch (D1517). The code is reported once per appliance. The arch is in the code itself, so there is no quadrant to add.
The choice that drives payment: one D1516 or two D1510
When a child loses primary molars on both sides of the upper arch, the dentist can hold the space with one palatal appliance (D1516) or with two separate band-and-loop appliances, each billed as D1510 per quadrant. That is a clinical choice. The claim should match what was actually cemented.
Payers do not agree on which one they prefer:
- Delta Dental of Michigan says two fixed unilateral appliances may be used in place of a fixed bilateral maintainer.
- Blue Cross Blue Shield of Arizona Health Choice (policy D0019, reviewed October 2026) defaults coverage to a bilateral appliance when primary molars are missing in more than one quadrant of the same arch. It makes an exception when the permanent molars have not erupted, or when medical necessity supports another design.
The fee gap explains why the second rule exists. South Dakota Medicaid’s children’s schedule effective July 1, 2026 pays $318.85 for D1516 and $260.07 for each D1510. Two band-and-loops on that schedule cost the program $520.14, against $318.85 for one palatal appliance. A plan with a bilateral default may pay the D1516 fee on a claim for two D1510 units, or deny one of them.
When the upper arch qualifies
A Nance or transpalatal arch needs permanent molars to anchor on. Blue Cross Blue Shield of Arizona Health Choice covers D1516 for early loss of both upper second primary molars, or of both the first and second primary molars on one or both sides, once both upper permanent first molars have erupted. Its policy states that D1516 is not indicated until both have erupted.
That makes the upper bilateral appliance a later-stage option than the distal shoe (D1575), which holds space for a first permanent molar that has not come in yet.
The general not-necessary triggers apply here as they do to every space maintainer. Delta Dental of Michigan lists, among others, a permanent successor about to erupt, space already lost, an abutment tooth with a poor prognosis, and an appliance that impinges on soft tissue. UnitedHealthcare’s policy DCP035.11 (effective March 1, 2026) also lists severe existing crowding, and poor hygiene or compliance.
What D1516 is not
- The lower arch. A lingual holding arch on the lower molars is D1517.
- A removable appliance. A removable upper maintainer spanning both sides is D1526.
- An orthodontic appliance. UnitedHealthcare defines a space maintainer as a passive appliance. A transpalatal arch used for anchorage during comprehensive orthodontics belongs to the orthodontic case, and Delta Dental of Michigan treats retention after comprehensive orthodontic treatment as part of those services, not space maintenance.
- A later visit on the same appliance. Re-cementing or re-bonding a loose Nance or transpalatal arch is D1551, and removing it is D1557. Both are upper-arch codes, and neither is another D1516.
Whether D1551 and D1557 pay separately is plan-dependent. DC 37’s Delta Dental code list (effective February 2024) limits D1551 to once in 12 months and pays D1557 on professional determination, both for children under 14.
Documentation for the claim
When a plan reviews D1516 for medical necessity, Delta Dental of Michigan asks for:
- Diagnostic radiographs of the areas of tooth loss that show the developing permanent teeth and the molars being banded.
- A diagnostic rationale in the record explaining why the space needs holding, with relevant dental and medical history.
Chart the primary teeth lost on each side and their dates, and note that both upper permanent first molars are erupted. That last line answers the eruption question before a reviewer asks it.
Common denials
- Bilateral default applied. The claim shows two D1510 units in the upper arch and the plan pays one bilateral fee instead.
- Molars not erupted. The plan’s criteria, like Arizona’s, require both upper permanent first molars in the mouth.
- Successor close to eruption. The radiograph shows the premolars near the surface, so the plan finds the appliance unnecessary.
- Age or frequency. The patient is past the plan’s age limit, or the arch already had a maintainer inside the plan’s window. Limits vary by plan.
- Orthodontic context. The appliance was placed during or after comprehensive orthodontic treatment.
FAQs
- What is the CDT code for a Nance appliance?
- D1516, the fixed bilateral space maintainer for the maxillary arch. A transpalatal arch uses the same code. CDT names the appliance by arch and by whether it spans both sides, not by design, so the Nance button and the plain palatal wire are both D1516 when they are placed to hold space.
- Is D1516 billed per quadrant or per arch?
- Per arch. The upper arch is built into the code, so one appliance is one unit of D1516 with no quadrant. Only the unilateral space maintainer codes, such as D1510, are reported per quadrant.
- Can we bill two D1510 units instead of one D1516?
- Bill what was placed. If the dentist cemented two separate band-and-loop appliances, that is two units of D1510; if one appliance crosses the palate, it is one D1516. What the plan pays is a separate question. Delta Dental of Michigan accepts two unilateral appliances in place of a bilateral one, while Blue Cross Blue Shield of Arizona Health Choice defaults to a bilateral appliance when primary molars are missing in both quadrants of an arch.
- What code is used to re-cement or remove a Nance appliance?
- Re-cementing or re-bonding it is D1551, and removing it is D1557. Both are specific to the upper arch, like D1516. Whether either is paid separately, and whether removal by the office that placed the appliance is included in the placement fee, depends on the plan.
- Is a transpalatal arch placed during braces billed as D1516?
- Usually not. A space maintainer is a passive appliance that holds space after early loss of primary teeth. A transpalatal arch used for anchorage or retention in comprehensive orthodontic treatment is part of the orthodontic case, and Delta Dental of Michigan lists post-orthodontic retention as a reason a space maintainer is not appropriate.
Related codes
Need help billing this code?
We handle D1516 claims daily.
If your team is spending time on denials, narratives, or carrier follow-up for this code, our dental insurance verification service can take it off your plate. We submit the claims, post what comes back, and follow up on anything unpaid.
“Claims, posting, denials, all of it gets handled, and it costs far less than hiring another employee. My front desk got hours of their week back, and honestly I just don't think about billing anymore.”
CDT codes are maintained by the American Dental Association. This page is an editorial billing guide, not the official ADA code descriptor. Verify current coverage policies with each carrier before submitting claims.